Jeffs John Cheap Car Insurance stands at number 1 in the list of cities with most expensive car insurance rates in Illinois with a indexing difference of $1523. This means that the car owners in Chicago IL pay $1523 more in car insurance premium than the Illinois state average and $2073 more than the national average. This make it even more important for you to shop for a few car insurance rates before you buy your policy. Exactly where we fit in for you. Timing: Mon - Sun Open 24 Hours